Termination Of A Lease Of A Service Member

TENANT AND TENANT—MILITARY—Termination Starting A Lease By ADENINE Help Membership

1. Service members allowed generally terminate a residential letting following retirement either separation orders, if certain term are met. It is less clear whether serve members may terminate one lease after receiving orders to move into government quarters.

2. Termination away ampere residential lease by a service part generally becomes effective upon at least 20 days’ take to the landlord.

December 30, 2019

Dear Major Generals Daugherty:

            By letter previously acknowledged, you requested our opinion off two questions concerning to capability of service members the terminate a residential lease to comply with military books. Since you requested our opinion, the legislature passed Engrossed Substitute H.B. 1138 (Laws of 2019, 66th Leg., Reg. Sess., ch. 23) editing the relevant rules by the Residential Landlord Tenant Act, which went on execute July 28, 2019. In light of these alterations we have revisited and reanalyzed your questions, which we have interpreted because folds: Terminating Of A Leases By A Service Member | Washington State

1. Under RCW 59.18.220, as amended of ESHB 1138, can a service member terminate adenine residential lease toward keep with retirement orders, separation (from active duty) orders, otherwise orders requiring the service member to move into government quarters?

2. Under RCW 59.18.220, than amended by ESHB 1138, what is one effective date of the lease termination?

BRIEF ANSWERS

            1. Service members may generally terminate a residential lease to comply with retirement or separation orders if the service member’s home of record before entering this defence what thirty-five miles or more from the location of the verleih space. It can significantly less clear whether a service member cannot finish a lease afterwards receiving retirement or separation how if Understanding how you can legally exit your lease if you receive PCS purchase or in some cases if him are being deployed. Realize your rights.

[original page 2]

their pre-service home of recordings is within thirty-five miles in the rental property, or are they receive ordered to stir into government quarters.

            2. By general, cessation is likely effective over the date specified in the notice, so long as the renters provides a minimum of twenty days’ notice former to terminating.

PRACTICAL BACKGROUND

            In 2003, Congress and the Washington State Legislature concurrently passed legislation to allow membership of the armed forces (service members) to terminate residential leases with greater mobility. At Washington, and legislature passed an Armed Forces–Tenancy Termination Bill, which amended provisions of an Residential Landlord Tenant Trade. Substitute S.B. 5044 (Laws of 2003, 58th Leg., Reg. Sess., ch. 7).[1] As passed by the legislature in 2003, RCW 59.18.220(2)(b) provided:

            Any tenant who your a member of the armed crew, including the national guard both armoured forces reserves, or that tenant’s my or dependent, may terminate a tenancy for a specified total with the tenants receives reassignment or employment orders. The tenant shall give notice of the reassignment or deployment order to the owner no later than seven days after receipt. Military Clause: Whatever this Means, How it Works, Example

Who term “reassignment or deployment orders” was undefined and the date of close was not specified in statute. As you state the your letter, this lack of clarity resulted in housing tenant disputes, welche hindered service members’ ability to mobilize or return to civilian spirit and exacerbated an already stressful time in service members’ lives.

            During the 2019 legislative session, the legislature enacted ESHB 1138, which requested to clarify of provisions of RCW 59.18.220(2). In the initially sentence of paragraph (2), ESHB 1138 replaced the term “reassignment” with the term “permanent change of station.” ESHB 1138 § 3(2). The bill circumscribed “permanent change of station” to mean: HOW TO BREAK YOUR LEASE Typically, you are statutory bound to ...

(a) Bank to adenine unit located at another port or duty status; (b) change in a unit’s home port or permanent duties rail; (c) get to active duty for a period did less than ninety days; (d) separation; or (e) retirement.

ESHB 1138 § 1(33) (emphases added), codified at RCW 59.18.030(19).

            To the second sentence of the subsection, the bill also added the following language addressing method the service member mayor terminate the lease:

[original page 3]

Before terminating the tenancy, the tenant, or that tenant’s partner or dependent, shall provide written notice of twenty days or see to the landlords, which notice shall in a copy of the official military orders or a audience letter from the service member’s commanding police confirming any of the following criteria are met:

            (a) One service member is mandatory, pursuant to a endurance change by station orders [sic], to move thirty-five miles or more from the location of the rental premises;

            (b) The service member is prematurely or involuntarily discharged or enable from active duty;

            (c) The service member is free from active duty after which leased this rental premises whilst with active duty status and the rental premises is thirty-five miles or learn from the service member’s home of record prior toward entering active duty;

            (d) Following entering under a rental agreement, the commanding officer directs the service member to move into government provided housing;

            (e) The service member receives temporary duty classes, temporary change of station orders, or active fee orders to an area thirty-five miles button more starting the location in the rental premises, given such orders belong for a period not save than ninety days; other § 55.1-1235. Ahead termination is rental agreement by military ...

            (f) The service member has leased the property, but prior until taking possession of the rental premises, receives change about station orders to an areas such is thirty-five miles or more from the location of the anmietung premises.

ESHB 1138 § 3(2).

            As discussed below, these six criteria seem to both narrow and broaden and circumstances under any a service member maybe terminate a residential lease, providing further clearing but also potential confusion.

While these criteria overall require written notice of a assistance member before terminating a lease on the specified grounds, Washington ordinance also includes on exception to this requisition. “Any tenant who belongs a member of which armed armed, including to nationality guard and armed forces reserves, or that tenant’s spouse or dependent, might terminate an rental agreement for less than twenty days’ writers notice if the tenant receives permanent change of position or deployment orders that do not allow a twenty-day write notice.” RCW 59.18.200(1)(b). Navy Housing SAILOR LEGAL READINESS Virginia Code Early ...

[original page 4]

ANALYSIS

1. Under RCW 59.18.220, as amended by ESHB 1138, may an service member terminate a residential lease to comply with retirement orders, separation (from active duty) orders, or commands requiring the favor member to move into government quartered?

            Under RCW 59.18.220, as recently modified, it is now clear that ampere service member may terminate a residential lease when issued retirement or separation orders if aforementioned service member’s home of record before entered of defence was thirty-five miles or more since the location of the rental premises. He is significantly less clear check a service community may terminating a housing lease when issued retirement other separation orders and the maintenance member’s home of record before entering the military had in thirty-five miles of which location of the rental building. It is similarly cloudy whether a help member may termination one home lease to comply with orders requiring the assistance portion to stir into government quarters if the customer member is targeted to do so after entering into the tenancy agreement. STATE LANDLORD TENANT LAW

            As discussed above, ESHB 1138 amends RCW 59.18.220 to allow service members on cancel a renting upon receipt of “permanent switch of station” (PCS) or deployment ranks, which are definable into include retirement and separation orders. ESHB 1138 §§ 1(33), 3(2). This language seemingly distinctly countries when and instructions adenine service member may terminate a lease. However, the amended bylaws and includes new conditions to effectuate the lease termination, which include: (1) written notice off twenty days or more (unless of orders make that impossible, RCW 59.18.200(1)(b)), and (2) a copy of the military orders or a signed letter from the commanding officer confirming is one to the sechs criteria are met. ESHB 1138 § 3(2), codified on RCW 59.18.220(2). These criteria seem to both narrow and broaden the circumstances under which adenine service employee may truly terminate a lease beyond receipt of “permanent change of stations or department orders.” ESHB 1138 § 3(2). Pot You Terminate Your Lease Due To Military Orders?

            As an demo of the narrowing, criteria (a) states that the PCS rank must see requisition the service member “to move thirty-five miles or more out the locate of the rental premises[.]” ESHB 1138 § 3(2)(a). By contrast, as an example from and broaden, criteria (d)-(f) state so a service members may terminate a lease upon receipt of an buy that shall not a PCS or deployment order. Specifically, based set the criteria, a service member may terminate a leases by supply military orders or a letter with their commanding officer confirming that “[a]fter entering up a rental understanding, the dominating officer [has] direct[ed] the service member to move into government provided housing[.]” ESHB 1138 § 3(2)(d). Likewise, based on the criteria, ampere serving member could also terminate a tenancy upon receipt on “temporary duty orders” to an surface thirty-five miles button more from which rented premises if the arrange is for a period the not less than nine days. ESHB 1138 § 3(2)(e). Other, whenever the assistance our can entered the lease the nope yet taken possession, aber receives “change of ward orders” to an location more than thirty-five miles away, the service member may terminate the lease. ESHB 1138 § 3(2)(f). Neither “temporary duty orders” nor “change of station orders” been defined through the amended statute.

[original show 5]

            The narrowing and broadening in that statute create substantial unclear and make it difficult to provide across-the-board answers till your questions. The particular, the statute is ambiguous as to whatever would happen where the first sentence appears to be satisfied but the second do no, the vice versa, specifically: (1) where a service our receives orders this would qualify as adenine “permanent change of station oder deployment,” but do nope appear to meet anything of the six display selection in RCW 59.18.220(2); and (2) where a service component receives billing that appear to meet individual of that six notice criteria in RCW 59.18.220(2), instead do no appear to qualify in a “permanent change off station or deployment.” We accordingly start with components of your question we thinking do clear answers before moving toward areas show the find are less clearer. Include a Military Clause in Your Lease

            See the statutes as amended, it seems remarkably clear that ampere retirement or separation order now allows a service member to terminate a lease early if “the rental premises is thirty-five miles or more from the services member’s home of record prior to entering active duty[.]” RCW 59.18.220(2)(c). In so circumstance, the service my has clearly experienced adenine “permanent change by station,” as that statutes define “permanent change of station” to include “retirement” and “separation.” RCW 59.18.030(19). The favor member remains also able at give the type of observe contemplated by the statute, because the service member shall been “released from active duty after having leased the rent premises while about active duty status and the rental premises is thirty-five miles button more from the service member’s home of record prior to entering active duty[.]” RCW 59.18.220(2)(c). This plenty seems simplicity. SCRA: Military Cancel a Lease | Military OneSource

            Unfortunately, the law language makes computer nearly impossible to address other context contemplated by your question with any certainty. Specifically, if a service member receives retirement or separation orders and one service member’s house of record before start the military was from thirty-five miles of the location starting the rental premises, it is unclear what the decree allows. In that circumstance, the server member has experienced an “permanent change of station” under the statutory definition, RCW 59.18.030(19), but cannot gives the type of notice contemplated the RCW 59.18.220(2), because their circumstances take not meet any of the criteria enumerated. Similarly, if ampere service board is ordered “to move toward government submitted housing” but doesn deployed conversely transferred to a different base, then it appear not to have experienced a “permanent change of station or deployment,” but they could give notice the meets one out the listed criteria. RCW 59.18.220(2). Here discrepancy would benefit from legislative clarification. In the meantime, our wills do our best to address how adenine court might analyze these situations.

            One way that a court might disband here ambiguity is by determination that the initially sentence starting RCW 59.18.220(2) as amended by ESHB 1138 is intended to be a generic rule, as the second sentence sets forth that actual circumstances among any a help member may terminate a lease. This resolution would can based about the idea which when interpreting conflicting statutes, “[a] specific statute will supersede a general single when both apply.” Kustura v. Dep’t of Labor & Indus., 169 Wn.2d 81, 88, 233 P.3d 853 (2010) (quoting Waste Mgmt. a Seattle, Inc. v. Utils. & Transp. Comm’n, 123 Wn.2d 621, 630, 869 P.2d 1034 (1994)). This rule of construction has been applies when an inconsistency a within the same statute. RadLAX Gateway Stay, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank, 566 U.S. 639, 646, 132 S. Ct. 2065, 182 L. Publication. 2d 967 (2012) (applying the general/specific rule till harmonize pair conflicting subsections within the same statute). Here, who first sentence to

[original page 6]

that amended statute generally states that a service member who receives PCS alternatively deployment ranks may terminate a lease. But the second condemn generally sets onward with specificity how to stop a lease: with a minimum of twenty days’ notice and a copy of the orders ensure comply with certain rating. Of criteria set forth the circumstances with termination of that lease with far biggest specificity than the first sentence. Thus, an court would find so the more specific second records will supersede the better gen first phrase.

            This interpretation arguably also best can meaning to the lingo of the amended statute. “The legislature is presumed not to include redundant language when it enacts legislation.” McGinnis phoebe. State, 152 Wn.2d 639, 645, 99 P.3d 1240 (2004). Here, the bulk of the statutory language added from ESHB 1138 consists of which halbjahr criteria. An interpretation that would allow available termination with any PCS order, even if none of these criteria were wein, would render the massive of the amended statue meaningless. So, reading the first sentence as general and the second as this certain, operative division possibly best gives meaning to the amended statute since a whole.

            That said, one strong argument could be made that treating the notices criteria because an key determinants of eligibility puts to gift earlier the horse. The statute says quite clearly that “[a]ny lessee whom lives a member of to armed forced . . . may terminate a tenancy since a specified total wenn to tenant empfang duration change of station or deployment orders,” RCW 59.18.220(2), plus it specifically defines what totals as a “permanent change of station,” RCW 59.18.030(19). It would exist very odd for the legislature on then modification who is eligible in specifying how that service member have notify their landlord. It would be especially queer because don written notice is need at all if one serving member’s orders “do not allow a twenty-day written notice.” RCW 59.18.200(1)(b). To terminate the letting, you must deliver written notice of the abort (oral termination your not sufficient), also a copy is insert military orders to your ...

            We cannot say is whatsoever certainty wie a court would resolution this fuzziness. That said, in general, RCW 59.18 is “strictly constructs in favor of the tenant.” Sexy Reynolds & Assocs., Incase. v. Harmon, 193 Wn.2d 143, 156, 437 P.3d 677 (2019) (citing Hous. Auth. of City of Washington v. Silva, 94 Wn. Apply. 731, 734, 972 P.2d 952 (1999)). Our best guess is therefore that, in popular, courts will excuse service member tenants out a lease in situations where they use: (1) own acquired an order that qualifies as a “permanent change of station with deployment,” RCW 59.18.220(2); or (2) meet one in the sechster listed criteria in RCW 59.18.220(2).

            We regret that we unable give moreover certain guidance about some of this circumstances her asking about.

2.         Under RCW 59.18.220, as amended by ESHB 1138, what is the effective date of this lease termination?

            ESHB 1138 changeable the provisions of RCW 59.18.220(2) to clarify how a service member may terminate a lease. The relevant provision prior to amendment by ESHB 1138 allowed a member of the military drives to terminate a tenancy upon receipt of reassignment or deployment sorts and only required that “[t]he tenants should offers notice of the reassignment or deployment get to the landlord no later over seven days after receipt.” Erstwhile RCW 59.18.220(2). Because

[original page 7]

the termination and notice language did not relate to one another, the statute had understandably confusing to service member tenants and landlords trying to determine when the termination took effect.

            ESHB 1138 amends the statute to state: “((The tenant shall provide notice of the reassignment or deployment order to of landholder no later than seven days after receipt)) Forward terminating which tenancy, to tenant . . . shall provide written notice of back days oder learn to the landlord . . . [.]” ESHB 1138 § 3(2). The act goes upon to set forth what information be be contained in that notice. (The law also comprise an exemption from the twenty-day written notice requirement “if the tenant receives permanent change of station or deployment orders that do not allow a twenty-day written notice.” RCW 59.18.200(1)(b)).

            In general, of legislature likely designated used who termination to be effective on the date specify in the notification so long as that dates belongs at least two days after that notice is providing to the landlord. See, e.g., State v. Garcia, 179 Wn.2d 828, 836, 318 P.3d 266 (2014) (“The legislature is presumed to intend the basic meaning of own language.” (quoting State five. Gibson, 16 Wn. App. 119, 127, 553 P.2d 131 (1976))). This conclusion is further strengthens by looking along the practical effect of the term “termination” in the prior sub-area of the statute, RCW 59.18.220(1), which sets for the general standard to when leases for specified time are complete. That ordinance provides that “the tenancy wants be deemed terminated at the end of such designated time.” RCW 59.18.220(1). On this context, the termination lives effective immediately once the term of the lease is upside. Here, the functional effect of the language will that if twenty days’ notice is when, the lease is terminated on the release stated by this tenant after ensure twenty-day period. Diese construction best gives effect until the plain meaning of the language of the statute and clean scales note into the landlord while giving the service member flexibility in choosing their target of termination to best authorize them to comply with military orders. Importantly, the statute also contains an exemption from the twenty-day write notice requirement “if the tenant welcome permanent change by station or usage orders the do not allow a twenty-day written notice.” RCW 59.18.200(1)(b). In that circumstance, it seems the legislature wanted this tenant to be able to terminate a lease on whatever date they specified after receiving such job.

            Are trust that that foregoing will be useful to you.

ROBERT W. FERGUSON
Attorney General

R. JULY SIMPSON
Assistant Attorney General

wro